Sydney chef awarded $18,200 payout after being fired after hospital stay


A Sydney chef who lost his job after being admitted to hospital due to cancer complications will receive an $18,000 payout as a result of his “unnecessarily harsh” treatment.

Chanintorn Siri had worked for wholefoods store Urban Orchard Food for more than two years when he was dismissed in November 2018.

Shortly before his sacking, Mr Siri was granted three days of sick leave by his employer after he was admitted to Concord Hospital in Sydney’s inner west after experiencing serious stomach pain as a result of pancreatic cancer.

But two days later, he was summarily dismissed during a telephone call.

According to Fair Work Commission documents, Urban Orchard’s owner Gabrielle Levette argued Mr Siri had been terminated due to his unreliability over the course of his employment, including alleged “serious misconduct associated with the fraudulent completion of timesheets”.

Ms Levette also claimed Mr Siri had previously closed the store early, taken sick leave without justification and been late for his shifts.

But yesterday, the Fair Work Commission found Mr Siri had been unfairly dismissed.

“This unnecessarily harsh approach was compounded by the extraordinarily heartless disregard for the personal circumstances of another human being who was suffering from pancreatic cancer,” commissioner Ian Cambridge said.

“ … the reason for the dismissal of the applicant was not sound, defensible or well-founded. There was not a valid reason for the dismissal of the applicant related to his capacity or conduct.”

Commissioner Cambridge said dismissing Mr Siri over the phone was “plainly unjust, manifestly unreasonable, unnecessarily harsh, and in this case, unconscionably insensitive”.

He originally ordered Urban Orchard to pay Mr Siri $26,000 in compensation.

However, that figure was then reduced by 20 per cent due to the “impact on the viability” of the company.

It was slashed by a further 10 per cent to account for Mr Siri’s likely further absence, meaning the former chef now looks set to receive $18,200 in total.

However, Ms Levette told the Sydney Morning Herald she was not aware of Mr Siri’s cancer, and the business would appeal the decision.

Shine Lawyers superannuation and employment law expert Will Barsby told employees couldn’t be “unfairly treated” for taking “reasonable and legitimate sick leave”.

“Each case is considered on its merit by Fair Work,” he said.

“You should check your workplace policy on sick leave and supply a doctor’s certificate when needed — some workplaces require a certificate even for one day off.

“Be upfront with your boss about what is going on to see if there is any flexibility while you get treatment or recover.”

Mr Barsby said insurance could help take some of the strain off workers who fall seriously ill.

“If you do run out of sick leave when you are seriously ill or are forced to quit your job, then we always encourage people to check their superannuation policies for access to income protection insurance,” he said.

“Depending on what your fund offers, it will pay you a percentage of your wage while you can’t work.

“There is also access to total permanent disability insurance through superannuation that gives you a lump-sum payment if you become too sick to work or you are diagnosed as having a terminal disease. There is quite a lot of paperwork when you apply for these insurances, but seek legal advice if you need it.”

Originally published via 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.